-
Carl Scheuber - 1921–1922, 1925–1930
-
Steve Harris - 1923
-
Earl Martin - 1924
-
Frank Kaiser - 1931–1933
-
Phil Cole - 1934–1936
-
Sheldon Gilleo - 1937–1938, 1943–1944
-
Seymour Tompkins - 1939–1940
-
James Daley - 1941–1942
-
William Lent - 1943
-
John Kavana - 1945–1946
-
Joe E. Carroll - 1947–1948
-
Thomas O'Connor - 1949–1950
-
Herbert Wienkoop - 1951–1952
-
Ed Foster - 1953
-
Henry Krasusky - 1954–1955
-
William Tice - 1956–1957
-
Robert Wessells - 1958–1959
-
Fritz Fulgum - 1960–1961
-
Charles Cordts - 1962
-
Joe W. Carroll - 1963–1964
-
Thomas Conklin - 1965–1966
-
Edward Miller - 1967–1968
-
John Lent - 1969–1970
-
John T. Jackson - 1971–1972
-
Harry Malles - 1973–1974
-
James Cole - 1975–1976
-
John E. Jackson - 1977–1978
-
Raymond Gilbert - 1979–1980
-
Edward Snyder - 1981–1982
-
Frank O'Connor - 1983–1984
-
Ron Anstett - 1985–1986
-
Joseph Jackson - 1987–1988
-
Richard Stickles - 1989–1990
-
James Matero - 1991–1992
-
Edward Kear - 1993–1994
-
George Gonda - 1995–1996
-
Scott Cole - 1997–1998, 2007–2010
-
Ken Gilleo - 1999–2000, 2010–2012
-
Robert Lockwood - 2001–2002
-
Brendan McGuigan - 2003–2004
-
Jack Kingston - 2005–2006
-
Peter Kolesar - 2014–2016
-
Scott Gilbert - 2017–2018
-
Michael Hanney - 2019–2020
-
Darrell Marriott - 2021–2022
-
Ryan Hojnacki - 2023–2024
-
Kyle Hanney - 2025
